Miriam Makeba sings Soweto Blues, by Hugh Masekala
How does this song make you feel? What emotions does it evoke?
Violence against Black South Africans came to a head in June of 1976. Thousands of students from schools in Soweto, a black neighborhood outside of Johannesburg, took to the streets to protest that schools would no longer be taught in native languages but in Afrikaans, the language of the Apartheid regime. Students from both high schools and elementary schools were met with force and gunfire from the police. Thousands were wounded and at least 176 were killed (although numbers are uncertain ranging from 23 - the government's number - to 700).
Sources A to F each emphasize a particular cause of the Soweto Uprising. Read and look at the sources carefully. When you are done, answer the prompt at the bottom of the page.
Source A
Statistics for Soweto 1976
- R = a Rand, South African currency - 8 Rand = $1.00
- Most people commute daily to work elsewhere in the Greater Johannesburg region.
|
From What is History? Skotaville Educational Division for the NECC, p 45
Think about the answers to the following questions to help understand the statistics above:
1.
|
If only 20% of homes have electricity, 5% of homes have hot water, and there is only one hospital
for 1.5 million people, what do these statistics tell us about the general living conditions in Soweto?
|
2.
|
Look at the average income for people living in Soweto. Compare it with their monthly costs?
What does this tell us about living standards of the general population of Soweto?
|
3.
|
Do you think that there was adequate schooling in Soweto? Use the statistics to prove your answer.
|
4.
|
If you lived in Soweto in 1976, based on these statistics, what would your major grievance
have been?
|
5.
|
How could these statistics help you to understand why there was such anger in the
townships in 1976?
|
Source B
Given black grievances ranging from low pay and poor housing to the pass laws and political repression, virtually any issue could have set off a generalized upheaval. The one that finally did was the regime's decision to implement a policy of teaching half the courses in African secondary schools in the southern Transvaal through the medium of Afrikaans.
From White Rule – Black Revolt by E Harsch, p 35
Source C
Students marching in Soweto on 16 June 1976
Bailey’s African History Archives, Mike Mzilen
Source D
No new secondary schools were built in Soweto between 1962 and 1971 because it was government policy that all new schools should be built exclusively in the homelands. As a result, secondary school classes were severely overcrowded and many teachers resorted to increasingly harsh methods to maintain control. Pupils bitterly resented this.
Adapted from Soweto: A History by P Bonner and L Segal, p 78
Source E
South African Student Movement’s efforts to promote political awareness were encouraged in 1973 when SASO students staged walkouts from black universities. Many of these ‘drop-outs’ became teachers in Soweto. Armed with BC ideology, they inspired a new spirit of radicalism. Many students tell of the impact these teachers had on them.
Adapted from Soweto: A History by P Bonner and L Segal, p 80
Source F
There was ‘an atmosphere of revolt’ in the 1970s. There were the liberation struggles in Mozambique, Angola, Zimbabwe and Namibia. There were the black workers’ strikes in the 1970s.
Quoted in The Right to Learn by P Christie, p 243
Source G
Baby Tyawa was a student who was involved in the Soweto Uprising. In an interview in 2003, she explains the significance of the uprising:
“It affected us both positively and negatively. A lot of us missed out on normal school. But it assisted us to know that the struggle for freedom needed the commitment and support of the liberation movements who were then banned, as well as leaders who were imprisoned. It set in our lives the role of full-time activism. The Soweto Uprising changed the history and landscape of the politics of the country permanently. Young people swelled the ranks of the liberation movements abroad, especially the ANC.”
Which source do you believe provides the most convincing explanation for the outbreak of the Soweto Uprising?
Provide a clear reason for your answer.
|
The international community was appalled by any nation that would
turn its guns on its own children.
- The United Nations called for a full scale embargo of goods and weapons that could be used by the regime against the people of South Africa.
- Universities who had investments in South African countries divested (got rid of) them.
- Economic boycotts of South African goods were called for all over the world putting a hole in the pockets of the wealthy industrialists who had been supportive of the regime.
- South Africans were denied access to international sporting events like the Olympics and FIFA futball.
- South African Airlines was denied the right to refuel in other nations when taking trans-continental flights.
- The boycott even went to the cultural realm. Tomorrow we will look at the cultural boycott
I believe source B is the most convincing explanation. The reason is because source B talks about the many struggles the people had, like we've discussed, but it ultimately clearly states that the teaching was the reason for the outbreak to begin. Source B is also from a primary source, which often give better understandings of situations.
ReplyDeleteEach Source is needed to be analyzed to understand the Soweto Uprising. Source A, however is the most convincing and provide the best information. Not only does it give you legitimate data of what low resources the common person has, it also asks you questions about the situation. Causing the reader/analyst to think about what each percent means and showing how low the sources are on the chart.
ReplyDeleteI think source D. It is very straight forward. They get to the point and also doesn’t waste time talking about the somewhat important points, it goes to the most important point. And i think it talks about a very big reason for the soviets uprising. And it convinces the reader right away.
ReplyDeleteI believe all sources were very convincing. Sources B and D specifically. But, I believe sourceD is the most convincing explanation. I think the point was very clear, and the evidence was used properly. Source D says that secondary schools were overly crowded. There were so many students in one class, because the Soweto government would allow new schools in their homeland. Teachers were overwhelmed with the students, they started to use more violent measures to discipline the children. Teaching played a huge role in the Soweto Uprising, so this source is very important.
ReplyDeleteIt looks like that all of the sources are convincing, but I’ll go with source B. I choose source B since source B is a primary source from White rule and with primary source it’s more real with more understandable information about the suffrage that black people had to face. It shows us an understanding that low pay and poor housing that couldn’t pay for education was the reason for the Soweto uprising.
ReplyDeleteI think Source A was the most convincing. It shows the statistics of the Soweto Uprising and how they do not align with each other. For example, the population and the number of hospitals and homes did not match up leaving many to be homeless and ill. There were also not enough schools to provide for the number of people leaving some uneducated.
ReplyDeleteI believe source B is the most helpful. It tells what they were upset about, poor housing, low pay, passing of laws, and then the final straw that started the uprising, teaching half the schools in Afrikaans.
ReplyDeleteI believe many of the sources but source A would be the one I believe the most because it gives flat out data about the living conditions of Africans just outside of Johannesburg. It seems as if it has realistic numbers to what was happening in the neighborhood. It's data looks like it gives all the information we need like the one hospital 1 million people had and the amount of money they were living off of like R140. It's definitely concerning since 8 Rand = $1.00.
ReplyDeleteI think source B was very helpful. It explained how they were getting very fed up and they only needed one more thing to push them off the edge. It explained how it wasn't even necessarily the thing that they protesting about but it was about the timing and they way that it took place that caused it.
ReplyDeleteSources B and D are best because they are direct quotes and information making it reliable. The evidence is supported well which is an important part of a good argument. Also the information about schools and children at this time gives a good look into the uprising from a different age group.
ReplyDeleteI believe that source D provides the most convincing evidence, because it blatantly states that students and teachers "bitterly resented" the conditions of the schooling systems. It also talks about harsh methods being used to maintain control, something that would definitely evoke some sort of lash back. Source D shows that eduction was clearly not a priority and that many were not happy about it.
ReplyDeleteI believe source B is the most helpful. It tells what they were upset about, and then the final straw that started the uprising.
ReplyDeletesource b is the most helpful because it was a primary source and gives alot of detail
ReplyDeleteI believe that source D is the best because it has good information and quotes. they have good evidence that is well supported, which is very imporatant for this argument. It also states clearly the conditions of schooling, and how teachers and students resent the conditions.
ReplyDeleteI believe that source B is the most convincing explanation. Source B talks about how the conditions were bad, and any issue could set off an upheaval. This source also says that the reason for the outbreak was the change in teaching. The book that the source comes from was published in 1980, which is only 4 years after the outbreak.
ReplyDeleteI think that source D provides the most convincing evidence. This is because, in the text, it explicitly says that "Pupils bitterly resented," that teachers were resorting to harsh methods of containment. This is clear cause for a resistance among the students.
ReplyDeleteI believe source D was the most thorough and informative out of all of the sources. It specifically tells you how bad it was and gives you very informational answers.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteI believe source B is the most resourceful and helpful, It tells what they were upset about. The low pay, poor housing, and passing of laws, and then the final straw that started the uprising, teaching half the schools in Afrikaans. Something that would affect all of their worlds.
I believe source B is resourceful because it shows us what made them upset when it came to poor housing, low pay, and political oppression. The also only taught half the schools in Afrikaans, which fumbled everything.
ReplyDeletei think source D was most convincing because it talks about government policy and it is a very informative answer and tells you all the things straight forward when you read it.
ReplyDeleteI believe that source D provides the most convincing evidence, because it blatantly talks about harsh methods being used to maintain control, something that would definitely evoke some sort of lash back. This source shows that eduction was clearly not a priority.
ReplyDeleteI believe source B provides clear evidence of why there was the Soweto uprising. It says that the blacks had many grievances, anything from low pay, political oppression, and poor housing. These definitely contributed to the uprising because these things were what they were upset about.It also said that anything could have set up the uprising but the one that finally did was the regime's decision to implement a policy of teaching half the courses in African secondary schools in the southern Transvaal through the medium of Afrikaans. This makes me convinced that these were the reasons for the uprising, everything combined, it was just too much for anyone to handle. It just wasn't right.
ReplyDeleteSource B is the most helpful. It describes the reasons people are upset and mad. With oppression, low pay, and poor housing it makes sense why they would be so upset causing an uprising.
ReplyDeleteSource D because it is straight forward to the point and explains everything clearly.
ReplyDeleteI believe source G is the most convincing. It actually brings the point of view of someone who experienced the event. It brings in a primary source so to speak.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, source B was the most helpful. It demonstrates one of the reasons people were so upset, they were required to pay extra for a necessity while already being oppressed.
ReplyDeleteI believe that source B was the more reliable source because it provides a brief but informational description on what took place. It gave reasons why it happened, and why they did it.
ReplyDeleteI chose source C because students are marching And I the image say that they do not want Afrikaans, and to fight to equal rights.
ReplyDeleteI think source A, because it gives a lot of data, and uses numbers. It might not tell much of a story, but brakes down pretty much everything. It also lets you see percentage.
ReplyDeletesource A is the most convincing because it has data to support its reasoning. We can look at the data and understand the impact that racism and poverty had and why the uprising finally happened.
ReplyDeletei think Source B was the most helpful because it breaks down and gives A lot of examples and things that happen to contribute to the uprising. I understand why they were upset they had low pay, poor housing, and they were oppressed.
ReplyDeleteI believe source B is the most convincing. They had already been docking there pay and supplies. They had them living in poor awful living spaces. So, as soon as they started teaching half the courses in African secondary schools they lost it.
ReplyDeleteI believe source D because it describes the situation and clearly depicts what is going on. The document is overall straight forward and easy to comprehend
ReplyDeleteSorce D because I feel like the person was actually there and it was very described
ReplyDeleteSources B and D are best because they are direct statements and data making it reliable. The evidence is supported well which is a significant piece of a good contention. Additionally the data about schools and children as of now gives a good investigate the uprising from a different age gathering.
ReplyDeleteI deem source B is the most convincing because kof how it mentions all of the struggles. Considering source B is a primary source, it makes it more reliable and likely to be true and all of the bad things said about how they lived would be very convincing.
ReplyDeleteI believe Source B is the most convincing explanation for the outbreak of the Soweto Uprising. It describes the reasons why the people are upset and fed up,With being political repression and poor housing and low pay these reason contributed to the uprising of soweto .The regime's decision to implement a policy of teaching half the courses in African secondary schools in the southern Transvaal through the medium of Afrikaans Set the uprising off for them .
ReplyDeleteI think source B was the most convincing because it told us how poor they were and how much they were suffering. The text told us how they lived in difficult living situations and how money was difficult to obtain.
ReplyDeleteThe source I believe provides the most convincing explanation for the outbreak of the Soweto Uprising is Source B because it explains how much they were suffering and how virtually any issue could have set off a generalized upheaval.
ReplyDeleteI believe source A because it gave believable statistics, which are needed to understand the unrest. The stats show that 20% of homes had electricity and 5% had hot water. They also had 1 hospital for 1.5 million people. These show why the people would be upset, they’re living terribly, most didn’t have anything at all. 70% or more didn’t have electricity or hot water.
ReplyDeleteI think source B provided the most believable explanation. The reason being is because it explains how they lived and how difficult it was. They where obviously suffering.
ReplyDeleteSource D. It gets right to the point and draws the reader in instantly.
ReplyDeleteI think that either Source C or Source D provide the most convincing explanation for the Soweto Uprising, as they both show the students emotions and get straight to the point.
ReplyDeleteSource B because of the information that it gave felt more convincing then the other ones
ReplyDeleteSpice B because they weren’t paid that well and they also were given poor housing by law. It helps us note how they were being treated
ReplyDeleteI believe the most convincing source would be source B because one it is a primary source and with primary sources the information is coming from first hand. Another reason source B is more believable is because it has emotion and can make the reader feel for the situation and person.
ReplyDeletePlease log in using your CPS email. This "unknown" post will be removed.
DeleteMaylani Hamler
DeleteSource B due to its straight foward approach, and how convinving it is, describing the situation clearly
ReplyDeleteSource A is the best in my opinion. Mostly because, the questions get you to realize on your own just how bad the conditions were. They get you to empathize with the citizens, and let you get a minor understanding of what they went through everyday. In effect that also shows why the Soweto Uprising happened, source A gets you to think "No wonder why the people wanted a change".
ReplyDeleteI think source B is the most supportive. It determines what they were disturbed about, and afterward the issue that crosses over into intolerability that began the uprising.
ReplyDeleteI think source A gives you an idea of the uprising. I say this because seeing the statictics you think what is going on. The monthly income is not even enough for their monthly needs meaning they are not even getting paid enough to survive. The question made you think and look at the statics a whole different way. The questions makes it so much worse like is they even still alive at this point cause the statics obviously they suffer from starvation. Basically shows that place was a living h e double hockey sticks. No wonder they wanted a change. they were living like animals.
ReplyDeleteI believe that sources A and B are the most convincing. A shows the appalling living conditions of the people in Soweto, while B gives other supporting reasons for revolt, such as the language switch. While the other sources are informing, I believe that sources A and B are the most straight-forward
ReplyDeleteSource B because it goes straight to the point.
ReplyDeleteI believe sources A and B are the most convincing/supportive. Source A shows the percentage of the overall conditions of the people. While the questions in source A makes you think of how devastating their situation is. While source B tells you straight-forward what they were disturbed about and the reasons for the revolt.
ReplyDeleteSoweto Uprising
ReplyDeleteMajor student protest movement
Set off by a government decree that black schools teach their students Afrikaans- language spoken by white South Africans
Police killed protesting student, march turned into revolt
Police crushed uprising
600 killed and 4,000 wounded
International community imposed trade sanctions and restrictions- attempt to force nation to abandon apartheid.
Yes! Please re-read the question and choose which of the above sources is the most convincing for you and why. Thanks!
Delete
ReplyDeleteI believe that source D provides the most convincing evidence, because it blatantly talks about harsh methods being used to maintain control, something that would definitely evoke some sort of lash back. This source shows that eduction was clearly not a priority
I think source A or D. Source A shows statistics that are very believable and trustworthy. Source D also because it gets straight to the point and doesn’t add extra information we don’t need.
ReplyDeleteSource D is very straight forward. They get straight to the point. It states that students and teachers were in bitterly resented conditions. And has a lot of quotes on the topic.
ReplyDeleteSource D because the government was taking away their right to have an education and made difficult for Africans to learn.
ReplyDeleteI'd go with source B since it shows what struggles blacks had to go through such as low pay and poor housing, as well as the issues they faced with poor decisions from their government.
ReplyDeleteAll the sources point to the reason for the uprising, because all together they paint a picture of Soweto. If I had to pick, I would choose source A, because it describes the material conditions of the people of Soweto, and not having resources can push a community to advocate for itself against the government.
ReplyDelete